June 21, 2018

US President Trump Cannot Legally Block Followers On Twitter, Rules US Judge

25 May 2018, 11:26 | Franklin Nunez

Thanks, Verified Liberals! Twitter Lawsuit Victory over Trump Could Make Internet More Free

Duke Med alumnus wins lawsuit against Trump for blocking him on Twitter

Today, however, a Federal judge ruled that blocking anyone from accessing the president's Twitter feed is a violation of the First Amendment to the Constitution.

The judge acknowledged that even though the president has certain free speech rights, he can not violate the rights of other Twitter users.

Eugene Volokh, a University of California Los Angeles School of Law professor who specializes in First Amendment issues, said the decision's effect would reach beyond Trump.

In other words, because Trump and his social media team are not in a position to control subsequent discussion of any tweets in the comment threads, then by blocking citizens from being a part of that public discussion they are limited their free speech rights. "Anyone with a Twitter account who has not been blocked may participate in the interactive space by replying or retweeting the president's tweets", she writes.

US District Judge Naomi Reice Buchwald ruled that such viewpoint-based exclusion is "impermissible under the First Amendment".

The seven users had each tweeted a message critical of the president before they were blocked. Among them was Rebecca Buckwalter, a writer and political consultant who was blocked in June after responding to Trump's tweet that he would have had "ZERO chance winning WH" if he had relied on the "Fake News".

- Can you sue the President of the United States and win? Instead, doing so limits their "right to speak in a discrete, measurable way".

During a hearing this year, she suggested that Mr. Trump could "mute" offending accounts so he wouldn't have to hear from them, but they could still interact with others beneath his tweets - a compromise that doesn't appear to have gained traction with the president.

The case was brought by aggrieved members of "Verified Liberal Twitter", a bottom-feeding group of Twitter users that cultivates likes, retweets, and followers on the platform by piggybacking on the President's tweets.

SpaceX Has 'Big Plans' For Reusable Falcon 9, Says Elon Musk
The only vacuum-optimized Merlin engine Falcon 9's second point includes a 5% push growth to 220,000 pounds-force, " he explained. The leading engineering minds at SpaceX have actually struggled over this ... "I believe we're in a fantastic situation".

Judge Naomi Reice Buchwald of the US District Court for the Southern District of NY sided with the argument made by the Knight First Amendment Institute at Columbia University that the president's Twitter feed constitutes a "designated public forum", and that Trump therefore can't block users based on their political views.

"The answer to both questions is no", Buchwald said in her 75-page judgement.

The U.S. Department of Justice had argued that the president and other public officials should be allowed to block people they see as irritants online in order to protect themselves.

Twitter, which wasn't a party to the lawsuit, declined to comment.

Judge Buchwald said that proved he was engaging in viewpoint discrimination.

The US Department of Justice, which represents the president in the case, said it disagreed with the ruling and is considering the next steps.

Jameel Jaffer, the Knight Institute's executive director, said in a release that his organization was pleased with the court's decision.

"The more important social media becomes to the public discourse, the more important it becomes to defend First Amendment rights on social media", DeCell said. "The court says this is a designated public forum and the general presumption is everyone can enter. If all goes well, Hollywood will immortalize him as an evildoer who got his comeuppance".

Other News

Trending Now

German leader argues for preserving Iran deal
But with few exceptions (Boeing is the one of significance), these sanctions don't really affect USA businesses. Iran's foreign minister says talks with the EU's foreign policy chief in Brussels were "constructive".

Israel, Turkey humiliate each others' envoys in escalating diplomatic spat
The Hamas-run Gaza health ministry said 60 Palestinians were killed and more than 2,700 more injured in Monday's clashes. Deputy Prime Minister Mehmet Şimşek and Finance Minister Naci Ağbal are also taking part in the meeting.

Jared Kushner: Security clearance restored for Trump's son-in-law
A background check of Kushner run by the Federal Bureau of Investigation took more than a year to clear. He is married to the president's oldest daughter Ivanka Trump.

Holy month of Ramadan to start tomorrow in Singapore, Middle East countries
On Tuesday evening the new moon was not visible in France, and Ramadan fasting was declared to begin on Thursday by default. This year, Ramadan will begin on Wednesday, the evening of May 16, and will go on till Thursday, the evening of June 14.

The 'Battlefield V' Trailer Just Dropped - Here's What's In Store
One of them will be told from the perspective of a female Nowegian Resistance fighter, battling against the German occupation. And yes, as you'll see in the following clip, there are also female characters in it.

US Market Indexes Close Lower on Tuesday
ENERGY: Benchmark U.S. crude oil gave up 15 cents to $71.16 per barrel in electronic trading on the New York Mercantile Exchange. The blue-chip Dow Jones grew by 68.24 points, with UnitedHealth and Walmart being the best-performing stocks in the index.

Man, 11-year-old girl killed during severe thunderstorms
As rain pounded the Northeast Tuesday night, wind gusts in the region approached 60 miles per hour , including in New York City. Residents in the Northeast and Mid-Atlantic are cleaning up after a line of severe storms hit the regions on Tuesday afternoon.

RED Will Launch the Hydrogen One on AT&T and Verizon This Summer
Both AT&T and Verizon announced today (May 17) that they will carry the Red Hydrogen One when that phone is released. This means the phone can handle 2D, 2D, AR, mixed reality and VR, all without additional hardware or headsets.

Kohli's RCB makes short work of Kings XI
Punjab have a tournament so far which can be easily divided into parts which is done by a one week break which was given to them. Ankit Rajpoot starts the over with a no-ball and Kohli Thumps a boundary on the next ball taking the win for his team.

High school seniors pull off epic prank in Wisconsin
In an unusual move, a police department in Wisconsin is actually praising high school seniors for their creative prank. They affixed black plastic to the wall around the auto so it seemed as if it had crashed through the brick structure.