Home » Art, Film, Reviews

Transformers 2: Less Than Meets the Eye

Film Review
The Transformers sequel is long and boring, and the extended action sequences were so over-stylized, the computer-generated special effects so intricate, reflective and bombarding, I really couldn’t make out what was going on.

By Peter Simek

Megan Fox and Shia LeBeouf run from the Decepticons in Transformers: Revenge of the Fallen
Courtesy Photo

After withstanding the two-and-a-half hour sensory onslaught that is Transformers: Revenge of the Fallen, I was squeezed in a crowd behind three eleven- or twelve-year-old boys filing out of the theater. There was a glow in their eyes as they discussed the intricacies of what we had all just seen: whose glowing heart power was ripped out when, what blow to which Decepticon ruptured what vital piece of computer-generated machinery to bring the bad guy down. I was a little worn out at this point. The Transformers sequel is long and boring, and the extended action sequences were so over-stylized, the computer-generated special effects so intricate, reflective and bombarding, I really couldn’t make out what was going on for much of the film. It is an ugly film, with a contrived plot and very few nail-biting, edge of your seat moments. The film lumbers like a wounded robot. But these young kids dug it. They likely have read the Marvel Transformers comics that were shuffled in my bins of comics at that age as well. They found VHS copies of the old cartoons I used to watch sitting on the floor of my parents’ bedroom after school. Surely they have the toys – the Transformers franchise, after all, was a merchandizing effort first, the storyline a second endeavor. And so for these kids, what we had just seen was exciting and memorable, the fodder for hours of nerdy conversations. It’s their film. I’m just the grumpy old guy who didn’t get it.

The comics of my youth – X-Men, Spiderman, Batman, Ironman, Transformers, and in a few months G.I. Joe – offer great material for studio blockbusters. They have proven stories and devoted fanbases. They potentially tap into new generations while sparking the curiosity of those who grew up with the stories and want to see them realized in a more visceral, transporting medium. Some of these comic-to-film stories have been able to access what are essentially solid stories – think X-Men and Batman – that both excite a child’s imagination and can sponge broader human themes. Transformers has that potential. It speaks to our anxieties about technology and the unknowns of the darks of the universe. It reads like a modern retelling of the Titans of ancient Greece, proto-gods whose battles, semi-gnostic struggles between the forces of good and evil, determine the fate of mankind. We live in an angst-ridden world, frightened by a sense of fate’s uncontrollability. Transformers is an apt fable.

But the new Transformers film doesn’t play to any of these themes. It’s just a action flick about a young guy starting college, Sam Witwicky, (Shia LaBeouf) who is buddies with the Autobots (the good guy Transformers), and has some sort of secret knowledge implanted in his brain that, he discovers, is a set of instructions to uncover a long-hidden tomb that contains a powerful energy (gnosticism’s appeal is in the accompanying adventure story). The Decepticons (the bad guy Transformers) want this energy because they can use it to power up a huge ray gun that destroys stars, and they want to destroy the sun (just because they’re bad guys), and with it, Planet Earth. That weapon is hidden in the pyramids (makes sense), and the final forty-five minutes of the movie are an action-packed showdown in the desert.

There are few tense moments, like when Sam and his bombshell girlfriend Mikaela Banes (Megan Fox) are hiding out in a little clay shack and a tiny robotic critter creeps through a peep hole and discovers them moments before the roof of the shack is torn off by a huge Decepticon. That part was fun. And like he is in The Taking of Pelham 1 2 3, John Turturro is a bright spot as the fast-talking, neurotic, ousted CIA Agent Simmons.

But Transformers: Revenge of the Fallen is remarkably ambitionless, a bang-bang, shoot-shoot film for young boys. If you are not a twelve-year-old boy, you’d do better dropping off the kids at the theater and renting an explosion flick that’s a little more inspired.

13 Comments »

  1. I saw this movie last night with my friends, and it was awesome!
    Very well made and incredible acting jobs for everyone!

  2. Liked it, way too long though.

  3. That’s the problem with critics. They can’t handle movies beyond 2 hours long. I’m glad, that I can appreciate lengthy films; i.e. Seven Samurai, Lawrence of Arabia, Ben-Hur, The Ten Commandments. Though, I have not seen this film yet, I am looking forward at viewing this film. Steadily approaching 40, all I can say is that one should not over-analyze a cartoon-turned-film. It was not meant to be a film that’s meant to impact one in an existential manner. It was meant to please kids and grown-ups that wish to be reminded of their childhood heroes. Most grown-ups, in the end have that child inside. It is what continues to fuel our creativity.

  4. Haven’t seen it yet so I can’t pass judgement, but I have to agree with Jose. Critics don’t tend to write good reviews for films over 2 and a half hours unless they’re tipped for oscars. So I think I’ll wait to see it for myself, because everyone I know who’s seen it liked it.

  5. Uh, for the record, three of my favorite films off the top of my head include The Best of Youth (6 hours long), Tree of the Wooden Clogs (3 hours long), and the Godfather (3 hours long). IJS

  6. I have 22 years (who sad that only kids loved it)and I loved the movie! It was fantastic I enjoyed every minute! I loved the cartoon when I was a kid and after these two films, I love them more then ever! Great job Michael Bay! I really don’t know what all this critic guys expect from this movie, to be like The Dark Knight or The Reader?! It’s a movie about giant robots kicking a**! I think neither of us expect from Transformers to be an Academy Award movie, but it really deserves Award for visual effects! People go to see the movie, it’s god damn amazing!

  7. In anticipation for this movie I drove my wife nuts. :) Being a huge TF fan and the dad of 3 boys we all we very excited for the film. We got to the movie and it took us quite some time to find a seat. The theature we were asighned was all booked up and it was only by chance that one theature had a pregnant woman that yelled at some people to move over so some little kids could watch a movie they have dreamed of for the last 5 months. As the movie progressed I found myself disipointed, which shocked me. I was extreamly dissipointed at the fact that the transformers were cussing. “Punk ass bitch” “Pussy” “Crazy Bitch”. Michal Bay I hope your ashamed of yourself. I told my three boys that if I herd them utter these words than I will swiftly remove all transformers merchindise from thier rooms. Transformers should never cuss, Yea spike did in the 86 film “O shit what are we gonna do now”, as did Ultra Magnus “Open Damnit open”. The first movie there were only two phrases uttered. “Whats cracklin little bitches” spoken by Jazz but it was so fast and garbled that my kids did not notice. And Frenzy in the end with the “O sit” when his head got choped in two. In hommage to the original movie Im sure. However, with this the movie lost me from the beginning. Ironhide…. for shame. Autobots… your advanced robots… why would you talk like that? I was disapointed. My kids loved the movie….. I was saddend. Oh well Gen 1 on DVD is comming out soon. Ill be happy with that.

  8. To the detractors above, why on earth are you reading “the critics” then?

  9. We should replace the current out of touch crop of critics…remember when Stanley Kubrick’s film 2001 came out and all the critics hated it…just sayin’

  10. So, grumpy old man, how old are you? For the kids…

  11. Everyone is entitled to their opinion, regardless of how missguided it may be. My opinion comes from having grown up with the transformers playing a major role in my childhood life, the first movie was absolutely nastalgic, and the opportunity to see my childhood heroes once again in action was a true gift to me. It just so happens that they added in great acting, flawless special effects, and regardless of how farfetched it was, a solid storyline that they not only made fit perfectly with the first one, but also added in the human elements of loss, pain, and love. I agree there was a lot going on in this movie, but it was far from boring. Perhaps before you pass judgement on something that you addmitadly were unable to follow in its entirety, another trip to the theatre would allow you catch the good parts of the movie you apparantly missed the first time around.

  12. was the best movie ever the godfather is trash compared to this movie it seems all u are looking for is nail bitting scenes they deffinitly made this movie perfect its hilarous, full of action, hot girls, there is even a lil love story going on this is definitly a movie that all types of people will enjoy in fact the only people ive seen that dont like are critics and im surprised yeah the movie is long but why cut it off in the middle and leave parts out if they would have done that u would have complained that it is incomplete but instead they finished the whole story in one movie so they can get to the next movie and there are many transformers to come i am sure america is going to make bay, labeaf, and fox the richest people in america

  13. Most of all: Peter Simik can’t write to save his life. I have never seen such boorish, sophomoric observation. AND THEN they are put forth in sentences worthy of their content. Sheesh. Find a writer. And a thinker.

    And it’s funny to see the ARBERY clan leap to his defense. He’s useless.

Have your say!

Add your comment below, or trackback from your own site. You can also subscribe to these comments via RSS.

Be nice. Keep it clean. Stay on topic. No spam.

You can use these tags:
<a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>